Should I Take Sumatriptan or Nurtec First?

Understanding Sumatriptan and Nurtec

In order to make an informed decision on whether to take Sumatriptan or Nurtec first, it is important to understand the purpose and effectiveness of each medication.

  • Sumatriptan: Sumatriptan is a triptan medication that works by constricting blood vessels in the brain to relieve migraines.
  • Nurtec: Nurtec is a CGRP antagonist that blocks the CGRP receptor to reduce inflammation and alleviate migraines.

Both Sumatriptan and Nurtec have their own benefits and considerations, and consulting with a healthcare professional is crucial to determine the most suitable medication for individual circumstances.

Learn more about measuring treatment efficacy through migraine tracking.

Factors to Consider

1. Individual Needs and Lifestyle Factors

Consider your individual needs and lifestyle factors when choosing between Sumatriptan and Nurtec:

  • Sumatriptan: Sumatriptan may be advantageous for individuals who experience sudden and severe migraines and prefer immediate relief during an attack. It is suitable for those who have a reliable response to the medication. For example, if you often experience migraines with intense pain, Sumatriptan’s vasoconstrictive action may provide quicker relief.
  • Nurtec: Nurtec may be beneficial for individuals with frequent or chronic migraines, as it can be taken as a preventive treatment. If you have migraines that occur more frequently or have constant symptoms, Nurtec’s ability to reduce inflammation may help in managing the condition on a more long-term basis.

Example: John, who experiences occasional migraines with intense pain, finds immediate relief with Sumatriptan. On the other hand, Sarah, who suffers from frequent migraines with persistent symptoms, prefers Nurtec as a preventive treatment to reduce the overall frequency and severity of her migraines.

2. Previous Treatment Experiences

Evaluate your previous treatment experiences to determine which medication might be more suitable:

  • Review your success or failure with previous treatments, tolerance and side effects experienced, and the effectiveness and duration of relief.
  • Identify any patterns or trends in your past treatment responses and any specific triggers or circumstances that may influence your medication choices. For example, if you have tried other triptans before and found them effective, you may consider starting with Sumatriptan.

Example: Lisa, who has tried multiple triptans in the past without success, decides to try Nurtec due to its different mechanism of action and positive clinical trial results.

3. Insurance Coverage and Cost

Check your insurance coverage for both Sumatriptan and Nurtec to understand their availability and potential costs:

  • Ensure that both medications are on your formulary list.
  • Confirm the copay or out-of-pocket expenses for each option. Some insurance plans may have different coverage tiers or require prior authorization for certain medications.
  • Explore any coupons or discounts available through patient assistance programs or manufacturer savings programs. These can help make the medications more affordable.

Example: Alex, who has limited insurance coverage, discovers that Nurtec has a manufacturer savings program that significantly reduces the out-of-pocket cost, making it a more affordable option for him.

Making an Informed Decision

To make a well-informed decision on whether to take Sumatriptan or Nurtec first:

  • Weigh the pros and cons of each medication, considering factors such as effectiveness, side effects, and individual preferences. Discuss these factors with your healthcare professional to determine the best choice.
  • Consult with healthcare professionals for personalized recommendations based on your medical history, previous treatment responses, and current symptoms. They can provide guidance based on their expertise and your individual circumstances.
  • Keep track of your personal treatment experiences and outcomes, documenting the efficacy and side effects of each medication. Sharing this information with your healthcare providers can facilitate ongoing evaluation and adjustments to your treatment plan.

Example: Emma, after discussing her options with her neurologist, decides to try Sumatriptan first due to its quick relief for her occasional migraines. She keeps a detailed record of her migraine attacks and responses to medication to evaluate its effectiveness.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Are Sumatriptan and Nurtec the only options for migraine treatment?

No, there are other medications available for migraines, including other triptans and CGRP antagonists. Sumatriptan and Nurtec are commonly prescribed and have proven efficacy in relieving migraines.

2. Can I take Sumatriptan and Nurtec together?

It is important to consult with your healthcare professional before taking multiple medications together. They can provide guidance on potential interactions and the best approach for your specific situation.

3. Can I switch from Sumatriptan to Nurtec or vice versa?

Switching medications should be done under the guidance of a healthcare professional. They can evaluate your treatment history and provide recommendations for a safe and effective transition.

4. Are there any long-term side effects associated with Sumatriptan or Nurtec?

Long-term side effects are rare but can occur with any medication. It is important to discuss potential risks and benefits with your healthcare professional to make an informed decision.

5. Can I use Sumatriptan or Nurtec as a preventive treatment?

Nurtec has been approved for use as a preventive treatment, while Sumatriptan is primarily used for acute migraine relief. Talk to your healthcare professional about the best preventive options for your specific needs.

6. Can I take Sumatriptan or Nurtec during pregnancy or while breastfeeding?

It is crucial to consult with your healthcare professional before taking any medication during pregnancy or while breastfeeding. They can assess the risks and benefits and provide guidance on the safest options.

7. Can I develop medication overuse headaches with Sumatriptan or Nurtec?

Overuse of any medication, including Sumatriptan and Nurtec, can lead to medication overuse headaches. It is important to follow your healthcare professional’s recommendations and use the medications as directed.

8. What are the common side effects of Sumatriptan and Nurtec?

Common side effects of Sumatriptan may include nausea, dizziness, and dry mouth. Common side effects of Nurtec may include nausea, indigestion, and fatigue. Consult with your healthcare professional for a complete list of potential side effects.

9. Can I develop a tolerance to Sumatriptan or Nurtec?

Tolerance to migraine medications can develop over time. If you notice a decrease in effectiveness, discuss it with your healthcare professional to explore alternative treatment options.

10. How long does it take for Sumatriptan and Nurtec to start working?

Sumatriptan typically starts working within 30 minutes to 2 hours, while Nurtec may take effect within 1 to 2 hours. However, individual responses may vary. Consult with your healthcare professional for guidance on timing.


Jenny from Migraine Buddy

You Will Also Like

Back to Blog

Leave your mobile to get a link to download the app